2020/8, 21 January 2020
Three recent opinion polls on Asian views of China as a major power show China’s growing difficulty in translating its growing economic and strategic weight (hard power) into trust of China as a leading power (soft power). All three polls show very low levels of trust in China as a major power and sharp declines in this vital component of soft power from 2018 to 2019.
Last week, ISEAS released its second annual State of Southeast Asia opinion poll of policy elites across the 10 Southeast Asian states. 60.4% of respondents expressed little or no trust in China “to do the right thing to contribute to global peace, security, prosperity and governance”, against 16.1% who expressed confidence in China. In 2019, the respective numbers were a less stark 51.5% and 19.6%.
Chinese official rhetoric portrays the country as a benevolent, status quo-oriented power that should not be feared or distrusted. In the 2019 ISEAS survey, 8.9% of respondents agreed that China was a benevolent power in relation to Southeast Asia and 22.5% viewed it as a status quo power. A year later, only 1.5% viewed China as a benevolent power and only 7.1% agreed that it was a status quo power.
The ISEAS results are very similar to those found in the 2019 Pew Center public opinion polling of 6 Asian countries (Indonesia, the Philippines, Japan, South Korea, India, and Australia). All six countries expressed more favourable views of the United States than China. Each national sets of respondents opted for the USA over China as a dependable ally and China over the USA as a source of threat. In 2019, five of the six Asian countries had less favourable views of China than in 2018. It would likely have been all six except India was not polled on this question in 2018.
The 2019 Lowy Institute public opinion poll of Australians reflected very similar views in relation to China as a major power. Only 32% of respondents expressed trust in China to act as a responsible major power. This was the lowest score for China in the decade-plus history of this poll by a wide margin and represented a drop of a full 20 percentage points from 2018.
These very similar results from three different polls reinforce the credibility of the results of each one and strongly suggest that China has a major soft power problem in Asia that is getting worse as China’s hard power increases. This is bad for China and for Southeast Asia.
Dr Malcolm Cook is Senior Fellow at ISEAS – Yusof Ishak Institute.
The facts and views expressed are solely that of the author/authors and do not necessarily reflect that of ISEAS – Yusof Ishak Institute. No part of this publication may be reproduced in any form without permission.